Friend Me Up on Facebook
Follow Me on Twitter

Why My Heirs Don’t Deserve a Dime

Posted in Rants Print This Print This

     The practice of handing over one’s wealth to their children and grandchildren after passing away has infuriated me for as long as I can remember—mostly because:

     1) I am not one of those children or grandchildren,

     2) The wacked-out principles behind such gifts, and

     3) What often happens to the money and the recipients.

      All four of my grandparents as well as my father had passed away before I was out of middle school.  I don’t remember receiving any inheritance, and I didn’t care about one then or now.  I’m sure that if someone in my family died and bequeathed a substantial amount of money to me, I would graciously accept it and do my best to put that money to work and not blow it on stupid stuff.  But that still doesn’t make it the best use of their funds and I’ll be darned if I do the same with mine.

     Of course, someone’s wealth is theirs to spend however the heck they want to spend it before and after death.  I just can’t understand why people feel the need to give money to children who have done absolutely nothing to deserve it.  Yes, you heard me.  I don’t believe anyone deserves to inherit anything.  It is a gift that someone may choose to give to their children, or they may find some place to give it that is even more wise and beneficial.

     Let’s say I die when I’m old and have an estate worth millions of dollars:

     1) What service have my children provided that justifies such a substantial compensation?  If anything, I think children should pay their parents to reimburse them for all of the time and hours spent teaching them, cleaning poo, and keeping them alive.

     2) What special needs do they have that justify hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars?  It would be one thing if they had a major medical condition that could be cured with a sizeable inheritance.  But if this were the case, I’d likely use the money for that purpose before dying and not after.

     I can hardly believe that my children need the funds from my estate more than starving people somewhere else in the world.  In all likelihood, my kids will grow up in middle-class neighborhoods, go to college, stay out of debt, and be able to provide for themselves.  Hopefully they will listen to what I have to say about becoming wealthy, but if not, I have no reason to believe they will not be at least middle class, (assuming there still is one in 20-30 years).

     So what on earth would make me believe that these privileged, self-supporting, and independent sons and daughters of mine need money more than people whose homes were destroyed by tsunamis through no fault of their own?  Or breadwinners in less-advantaged countries who could finally escape the shackles of poverty by starting a small business with the help of a micro-loan?

     But instead, people must think, “I love my kids.  I want to give them stuff.  When I die, I’m going to hand over to them on a silver platter everything that I, in comparison, have had to scratch, scrimp, save, and toil for my entire life.”  Dumb, dumb, dumb, dumb, dumb.

     I’ve had to work for every dollar I’ve earned—why should they be any different?  The idea of handouts is appalling.  Million-dollar handouts?  Gag me with a spoon.

     3) Will they even know what to do with it?  Do I even need to go into what happens the vast majority of times when the 2nd and 3rd generation receive money earned by the 1st generation?  It gets blown and the kids come out rotten.  I’ve seen it among my contacts, and there are several books and plenty of research on the subject.

     For these reasons, I might give them a nice bonus or something when I kick the bucket, like a down payment on a house.  But even then I’d make it conditional, according to the rules of my living trust, upon at least the following:

          A) Their mortgage payment is 1/3rd of their income or less, 

          B)  They have no consumer credit card debt, and 

          C)  They have not willfully misspelled any of their children’s names on purpose, just to be different (another pet peeve of mine).

     But any wealth I still have at that time, provided I didn’t spend it all on $1000/pill prescription drugs, is going to micro-loans or some other place where at least 90% of donated funds will go to recipients who really need it.

Worth Reading? Share With Your Friends:
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  1. 9 Responses to “Why My Heirs Don’t Deserve a Dime”

  2. By Eric Hundin on Apr 28, 2008

    I found your blog on MSN Search. Nice writing. I will check back to read more.

    Eric Hundin

  3. By Tim Ramsey on Apr 28, 2008

    I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.

    Tim Ramsey

  4. By Jason on Apr 28, 2008

    Beautiful post! I love a little, or a lot or controversy. I agree with you on this issue 96.4% (Pretty good considering I like to argue everything.)

    I think I am going to change the spelling (but not the pronunciation) of my name to jEEson. (The capitalization, and lack of, is on purpose, not a mistake, and there is one of those symbols that looks like two dots over the second E and a squiggly-line over the o. WARNING: I will be offended if you pronounce my name incorrectly from now on!

  5. By Lon on Apr 29, 2008

    Alan, I had never thought of it this way. Good entry.

  6. By Sherrie on Apr 30, 2008

    I am one of your new students. But I have to disagree with you. Every parent (i guess there are exceptions) wants there life to easier than theirs. And you want to give your child opportunity. But of course before you are willing to do this for them they must be responsible individuals. What would be the point if they weren’t. It is called upon us to build an inheritance for our children.

  7. By Vernon on Apr 30, 2008

    Great point! My wife and I have been discussing this very topic. How to raise our four children and subsequently establish a legacy (grandchildren and beyond) that will not fall into the same rut of poverty and wage-slavery our current and previous family & freinds have.

    We have noted some families have had success with this, but like you mentioned there seem to be far more that have not.
    It seems to be more important to show them by our actions, allow them to experience business/investing vs. 9-5 work, and introduce them to mind developing information (books, audios, seminars, etc.)

    Deserve/entitlement thinking seems to breed other problems in ones life. I don’t want to contribute to that type of thinking in my children.

    Good stuff Alan. I like your thinking.

  8. By Alan Brymer on May 1, 2008

    Sherrie,

    Couldn’t there be some way to give them every opportunity, but make the actual transfer of money conditional upon them doing or being something first, rather than just giving it to them?

  9. By John Bridges on Mar 22, 2010

    Love it! Les, you certainly have a way of thinking outside the box. I’m curious what Marshall Silver’s take would would be.

  10. By Mark on Apr 28, 2010

    I must be incredibly lucky or blessed, if you prefer. I have one child, and he has singlehandedly been the most rewarding life experience I’ve ever imagined. He’s smart, quick witted, genuinely cares for his fellow man, and through his actions I become a better person everyday. Why? He REMINDS me, by his actions to try to find the best in EVERYBODY. He nullifies any negative thoughts by sharing his positive thoughts and actions with me. Through his love for me, I find the strength to keep on keepin’ on, to plunge forward with a lighter step and a much better outlook. He is learning virtually everything I learn about real estate investing, and I’ll bet he’ll be a millionaire by 18, even though he is only 12 right now. It is my full expectation that this young man will not only inherit my business, he will build it larger and better than I did. I can’t think of a bigger privilege than to hand over the keys to a well seasoned, competant young man that knows how to deal with owners, private money lenders, buyers both retail and wholesale. He’s also being trained to give back to the world, which is close to his heart. I explain what to do and why to do it…. Give a man a fish, he eats for a day but if you teach ‘em to fish, the rest will take care of itself.

Post a Comment